My plan is renewing. How many brokers should I talk to and how many quotes should I get?

When your employee benefits plan is approaching renewal, it's natural to wonder whether you should invite several brokers to compete for your business.

After all, more competition should mean better pricing and more options, right?

Not necessarily.

More brokers don't always mean more choices.

Most employee benefits brokers have access to many of the same insurance carriers. When several brokers approach those carriers on behalf of the same employer, you may receive multiple proposals built around essentially the same underlying plans and pricing.

Rather than creating more choices, this can make it harder to understand what's actually different.

You may find yourself comparing presentation styles, spreadsheets, and recommendations instead of evaluating meaningful differences in coverage, cost, and strategy.

There's another consideration employers may not realize.

When multiple brokers submit the same opportunity to a carrier, the carrier knows the employer is being widely marketed.

Depending on the carrier, market, and funding arrangement, duplicate submissions can complicate the quoting process or require clarification about which broker is authorized to represent the employer.

In more complex underwriting situations, a focused and well-prepared submission may also create better opportunities for meaningful discussions about plan design, underwriting assumptions, and potential alternatives.

That doesn't mean employers should avoid competition among advisors. It means there's a difference between evaluating multiple advisors and having multiple advisors simultaneously shop the same insurance markets.

Choose the advisor before comparing the proposals.

Instead of asking every broker to bring you quotes, start by understanding how each one approaches your benefits program.

Consider asking:

• How do you evaluate our current plan? Do you look beyond premiums to examine employee costs, utilization, and plan design?
• How do you approach the insurance market? Which carriers and funding arrangements would you consider, and why?
• How do you evaluate trade-offs? Can you explain the financial and practical consequences of different options?
• How do you support our employees? What assistance do you provide with enrollment, communications, and ongoing benefits questions?
• What happens after renewal? How will you help us manage our benefits program throughout the year?

The answers can tell you far more about the value of an advisor than another spreadsheet of insurance quotes.

How many quotes are enough?

There's no universal number.

Sometimes two or three well-selected proposals provide enough information to make an informed decision. Other situations justify a broader market evaluation, particularly when an employer is considering alternative funding arrangements, different provider networks, or a significant change in benefits strategy.

The important question isn't how many quotes you've collected. It's whether you've explored the options that genuinely deserve consideration.

At MPOWR, we believe the market should be approached with a purpose. That means understanding your organization's priorities, identifying the carriers and strategies most likely to meet those needs, and evaluating the results in a way that makes the differences clear.

The objective isn't to generate the largest stack of proposals.

It's to help you make a well-informed decision with confidence.

‍